Pep Boys has named Chicago the top market in its second annual Worst Roads in America report, which ranks U.S. metro areas by how often drivers need road-related vehicle repairs. Chicago moves up from No. 2 last year and replaces Orlando as the highest-ranked market. Orlando now sits at No. 16.

The ranking is based on Pep Boys’ internal service data and identifies where alignments, suspension work, tire repairs, single-tire replacements and wheel balancing happen most often. Pep Boys noted that markets with above-average repair rates often face difficult driving conditions such as extreme weather, heavy traffic and ongoing construction. The company says the findings reflect vehicle repair trends, not measured road quality or government ratings.

The top 10

The top 10 metro areas in the 2026 ranking are Chicago; Nashville; Tampa-St. Petersburg-Sarasota; New Orleans; Panama City, Florida; Youngstown, Ohio; Charleston, South Carolina; Augusta, Georgia; Waco-Temple-Bryan, Texas; and Cleveland. The full list covers 30 markets.

Key findings

  • Southern markets make up 73% of the 2026 list, including markets in Florida, Tennessee, Louisiana, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Texas, Maryland and Virginia.

  • Florida, Alabama, Louisiana and Texas together represent 47% of all ranked markets.

  • Florida remains the most represented state. Orlando, Tampa, Panama City, Miami and West Palm Beach account for 17% of the list, ahead of Louisiana with three markets.

  • Eight markets make the list for the first time: Waco, Cleveland, Chattanooga, Shreveport, Birmingham, San Antonio, Memphis and Huntsville.

Chicago and Nashville

Pep Boys said Chicago’s climb was helped by Orlando’s drop, after Orlando’s tire repair and alignment indexes fell below the national benchmark. Chicago continued to post above-benchmark results in tire replacement and wheel balancing services. Pep Boys said harsh Midwest winters and repeated freeze-thaw cycles are patterns often associated with increased tire and wheel damage, which may help explain why Chicagoland drivers continue to see high repair rates.

Nashville rose from No. 7 to No. 2, the biggest jump among the top-ranked markets. The climb comes from an uptick in suspension work, with Nashville now outpacing the average market in suspension repairs. Pep Boys called suspension repairs a common sign of rough pavement, potholes and uneven road surfaces.

“The repairs we see in our service bays reflect the roads our customers drive every day,” said Ken Lichty, ASE Master Technician and Technical Trainer at Pep Boys. “Whether it’s tire damage or suspension wear, staying ahead of it with regular tire, alignment and suspension checks can help drivers avoid bigger repair bills down the road.”

How the ranking works

The report draws on Pep Boys service data from September 14, 2025, to September 13, 2026, across U.S. markets where the company operates. Puerto Rico and closed stores are excluded. Markets were scored on five categories: alignment, suspension, tire repair, single-tire replacement and wheel balancing. Each category is measured as a percentage of car count, except single-tire replacement, which uses tire car count.

A market earned one point for each category in which it over-indexed, meaning an index above 100, against all other markets, for a maximum of five points. Service work order count served as the tiebreaker.

Pep Boys recommends regular tire inspections, wheel alignments and suspension checks for drivers in high-repair areas. The company, with nearly 800 locations across the U.S. and Puerto Rico, is at pepboys.com.